Comparison

Sift alternative: LoginLlama vs Sift

Sift alternative for developers who want to start without a demo.

Side by side

Sift details come from Sift's own site as of 2026-11-03. Where the site does not say, this page says so. Confirm current details with Sift before you decide.

FeatureLoginLlamaSift
What it isA login risk scoring API: one call returns a 0 to 10 score and reason codes.Sift Account Defense detects account takeover by scoring logins on device intelligence, behavioural patterns, unusual account changes and network signals, so teams can allow, challenge or block. It also offers session-level controls, investigation summaries and post-login monitoring.
PricingPublished. Starter $9, Professional $49, Enterprise $199 a month.Not published. The site offers a demo request and a call with an expert.
Free tierYes: 100 free checks to start, no card.None listed.
SetupOne API call at login. SDKs for Node.js, Python and PHP, and a one-prompt agent install.Platform integration, arranged through Sift.

Feature by feature

Including where Sift does more than LoginLlama.

FeatureLoginLlamaSift

Login risk score

A score for each sign-in that your code can act on

0 to 10, risky above 5. Stricter for accounts sent with privileged: true.

Reasons with the score

Why a login scored as it did, in the response

Partial

AI-written investigation summaries rather than reason codes.

New device and location

Flags a device, network or country the user has not used

Device means browser and operating system from the user agent. There is no client-side SDK.

Impossible travel

Flags two logins too far apart to be the same person

IP reputation

Tor, VPN, hosting networks and addresses with a record of abuse

Brute force and credential stuffing

Counts failed attempts per account and per IP

Bursts of failures on one account, and one IP failing across many accounts. Needs your failed attempts reported too.

Partial

Mentions velocity signals, without naming brute force or credential stuffing.

Breached password checks

Flags a password that appears in known breaches

Device fingerprinting

A client-side SDK that identifies the device itself

Bot detection and challenges

Tells people from scripts, and challenges the scripts

Custom rules

Write your own policies on top of the signals

Sign-up abuse

Fake accounts and bonus abuse at registration

Post-login monitoring

Watches the session after sign-in

Investigation tools

Case queues and review tools for a fraud team

New-login emails to users

Emails the account owner "was this you?" for you

Works with any auth stack

Sits next to your own login, Auth0, Clerk or anything else

Self-serve sign-up

Get an API key without talking to sales

Published pricing

Prices on the website

Free tier

Use it without paying

100 checks to start, no card.

MCP server

Query your login data from a coding agent

A dash means the vendor's own pages don't say. Facts come from each vendor's site on the date shown. Spot something out of date? Email [email protected] and we'll fix it.

Choose LoginLlama when

  • You want to sign up, get an API key and run a first check the same day.
  • You want published prices. LoginLlama plans run from $9 to $199 a month.
  • You only need the login decision and you do not run a fraud operations team.

Choose Sift when

  • You need post-login monitoring and investigation workflows.
  • You have a fraud team that will use case-management tools.
  • You operate at a scale where a sales-led contract is normal.

What Sift does well

  • Post-login monitoring and session-level controls, which go beyond a score at the login step.
  • Investigation tooling for fraud teams.
  • Durable device fingerprinting that persists across sessions.

See every vendor in one table on the comparison page, or read how account takeover detection works.

Frequently asked questions

Is LoginLlama a good Sift alternative?

It is if your goal is to score logins for account takeover and credential stuffing. LoginLlama does that with one API call. Sift is the better fit in these cases: You need post-login monitoring and investigation workflows. You have a fraud team that will use case-management tools. You operate at a scale where a sales-led contract is normal.

How much does Sift cost compared with LoginLlama?

Sift: Not published. The site offers a demo request and a call with an expert. LoginLlama: Starter is $9 a month for 5,000 checks, Professional is $49 for 50,000 and Enterprise is $199 for unlimited checks. Figures for Sift come from its site on 2026-11-03.

Can I run LoginLlama next to Sift?

Yes. LoginLlama runs as one call at your login step and fails open, so you can score the same logins in shadow mode, compare the results, and switch when you are confident.

Instead of Sift

Score your first login in minutes

Free checks, one API call, no sales call.

Start with 100 free checks