Comparison

LoginLlama vs Castle, Sift, Arkose & Auth0

An honest look at how the main account takeover prevention and login fraud detection tools compare — by setup effort, pricing model, explainability, and who each one is really for.

Recommendations by team type

The right tool depends on who will act on the result. If you are not in the first group, one of the others is probably a better fit.

SaaS and B2B teams without a fraud team
LoginLlama. One API call returns a score and the reasons, and the user gets a "was this you?" email, so nobody has to watch a console.
Teams on any auth provider
LoginLlama. It sits next to your own login, Better Auth, Clerk, Auth.js or Auth0, so there is nothing to migrate.
Early-stage startups
LoginLlama. Published prices from $9 a month, 100 free checks, and you can be scoring logins the same afternoon.
Consumer apps fighting bots at sign-up and login
Castle. Bot detection, device fingerprinting and a policy engine, with a free tier to try it.
Mobile apps
Castle. Mobile SDKs that fingerprint the device itself, which a server-side check cannot do.
Marketplaces and fintechs with a fraud operations team
Sift. Post-login monitoring, session controls and investigation tools that a fraud team works from every day.
Enterprises under large-scale automated attack
Arkose Labs. Challenges built to make bots, AI agents and fraud farms expensive, managed by Arkose.
Teams already on Auth0
Auth0 Attack Protection. Brute-force protection and IP throttling are on every plan, so switch them on first. Breached password checks need Professional.

Feature by feature

Including the rows where LoginLlama is missing something. Plans and features change, so each vendor's page links its source.

FeatureLoginLlamaCastleSiftArkose LabsAuth0 Attack Protection

Login risk score

A score for each sign-in that your code can act on

0 to 10, risky above 5. Stricter for accounts sent with privileged: true.

Partial

A confidence score from Adaptive MFA, an Enterprise add-on.

Reasons with the score

Why a login scored as it did, in the response

Returns signals with the score.

Partial

AI-written investigation summaries rather than reason codes.

Partial

Adaptive MFA exposes its NewDevice, ImpossibleTravel and UntrustedIP results to Actions.

New device and location

Flags a device, network or country the user has not used

Device means browser and operating system from the user agent. There is no client-side SDK.

Partial

Device ID recognises returning devices. Location is not mentioned.

Partial

Adaptive MFA only. New device means not seen on the account in 30 days.

Impossible travel

Flags two logins too far apart to be the same person

Partial

Adaptive MFA only.

IP reputation

Tor, VPN, hosting networks and addresses with a record of abuse

Partial

Bot Detection and the UntrustedIP check use IP reputation. Enterprise only.

Brute force and credential stuffing

Counts failed attempts per account and per IP

Bursts of failures on one account, and one IP failing across many accounts. Needs your failed attempts reported too.

Partial

Mentions velocity signals, without naming brute force or credential stuffing.

Breached password checks

Flags a password that appears in known breaches

Professional plan and above.

Device fingerprinting

A client-side SDK that identifies the device itself

Bot detection and challenges

Tells people from scripts, and challenges the scripts

Partial

A CAPTCHA for suspected bots. Enterprise add-on.

Custom rules

Write your own policies on top of the signals

Auth0 Actions.

Sign-up abuse

Fake accounts and bonus abuse at registration

Partial

A tutorial covers blocking sign-ups from spam email domains.

Post-login monitoring

Watches the session after sign-in

Investigation tools

Case queues and review tools for a fraud team

New-login emails to users

Emails the account owner "was this you?" for you

Works with any auth stack

Sits next to your own login, Auth0, Clerk or anything else

Only for logins that go through Auth0.

Self-serve sign-up

Get an API key without talking to sales

Published pricing

Prices on the website

Partial

Plans are published. Enterprise and its add-ons are not.

Free tier

Use it without paying

100 checks to start, no card.

1,000 Risk API calls a month, 3 days of data retention.

MCP server

Query your login data from a coding agent

A dash means the vendor's own pages don't say. Facts come from each vendor's site on the date shown. Spot something out of date? Email [email protected] and we'll fix it.

When to choose LoginLlama

Choose LoginLlama when you want to add account takeover and credential-stuffing protection to your own login flow in an afternoon — without a sales call, a platform migration, or an enterprise contract. You get a real-time risk score (0–10) with clear reason codes from a single API call, free checks to start, and a fail-open design so a LoginLlama outage never blocks your real users. The larger platforms make more sense once you need a full fraud operations suite or are running at very large scale.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best account takeover prevention tool for a small team?

For a small or solo engineering team, the deciding factors are time-to-integrate and price. LoginLlama is built for this: one API call at the login step, 100 free checks to start with no credit card, usage-based pricing, and SDKs (plus an MCP server) so a coding agent can install it in a single prompt. Castle publishes its prices and has a free tier, so it is also easy to try. Sift and Arkose do not publish pricing and onboard through sales.

Is LoginLlama a Castle or Sift alternative?

Yes — for the specific job of scoring logins for account takeover and credential stuffing risk. LoginLlama is narrower and developer-first: it does real-time login risk scoring with explainable reason codes rather than a full fraud-operations platform. If you need end-to-end payment and content fraud tooling, a broad suite like Sift may fit better; if you mainly need to stop risky logins quickly and affordably, LoginLlama is the lighter, faster option.

How is login fraud detection different from a bot-mitigation tool like Arkose?

Bot mitigation (e.g. Arkose) primarily decides whether traffic is human and presents challenges. Login fraud detection scores the risk that a specific login is an account takeover — using device history, impossible travel, IP reputation, and credential-stuffing patterns — and returns a score you can act on without forcing a challenge on every user. The two are complementary; LoginLlama focuses on the risk-scoring layer.

Can I switch from another provider to LoginLlama?

Yes. Because LoginLlama runs as a single call at your login step and fails open, you can run it in shadow mode alongside your current tool, compare risk scores, and cut over when you are confident. There is no auth-provider migration required — it sits next to whatever you already use.

Account takeover prevention

Add login risk scoring without a sales call

Start with 100 free checks and block risky logins in real time.

Start with 100 free checks